Talk About Network

Google


Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


Programming > C++ Moderated > Public member v...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 1 of 39 Topic 9752 of 9909
Post > Topic >>

Public member variables acceptable?

by francis_r <francis.rammeloo@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Jun 28, 2008 at 01:27 AM

I made it a habit to always, without any exception, declare my member
variables private. However, there are some situations where it seems
that it's ok to make an exception. For example in a Point class:

class Point
{
public:
     Point();
     Point(int inX, int inY);

     int x;
     int y;
};

Would this be bad design?

On what principles would the decision to declare a member public be
based?


Kind regards,
Francis


-- 
      [ See http://www.gotw.ca/resources/clcm.htm
for info about ]
      [ comp.lang.c++.moderated.    First time posters: Do this! ]
 




 39 Posts in Topic:
Public member variables acceptable?
francis_r <francis.ram  2008-06-28 01:27:57 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
Seungbeom Kim <musiphi  2008-06-28 16:11:51 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
=?UTF-8?B?RXJpayBXaWtzdHL  2008-06-28 16:25:46 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
Martin York <Martin.Yo  2008-06-28 16:38:13 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
Pavel Minaev <int19h@[  2008-06-28 16:57:57 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
Francis Glassborow <fr  2008-06-28 16:58:01 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
"Bo Persson" &l  2008-06-28 16:58:00 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
Chris Uzdavinis <cuzda  2008-06-28 16:57:58 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
John G Harris <news0@[  2008-06-29 14:28:00 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
brangdon@[EMAIL PROTECTED  2008-06-29 14:27:59 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
Alan McKenney <alan_mc  2008-06-30 08:58:35 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
brangdon@[EMAIL PROTECTED  2008-07-01 19:52:19 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
Alan McKenney <alan_mc  2008-07-03 03:28:08 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
Ilian <ilianpinzon@[EM  2008-07-01 19:44:33 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
Martin Bonner <martinf  2008-07-01 19:51:09 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
Tony Delroy <tony_in_d  2008-07-02 04:22:45 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
"Nevin :-] Liber&quo  2008-07-03 03:28:08 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
Alan McKenney <alan_mc  2008-07-03 03:28:07 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
Francis Glassborow <fr  2008-07-03 08:54:50 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
Tony Delroy <tony_in_d  2008-07-04 19:29:45 
Changing coordinate systems in mid-development (Was: Public memb
Alan McKenney <alan_mc  2008-07-04 19:26:32 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
Tony Delroy <tony_in_d  2008-07-04 19:28:43 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
"Daniel T." <  2008-07-04 19:30:26 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
Alan McKenney <alan_mc  2008-07-07 06:22:42 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
Tony Delroy <tony_in_d  2008-07-08 03:18:17 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
Seungbeom Kim <musiphi  2008-07-08 05:25:49 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
Seungbeom Kim <musiphi  2008-07-08 05:25:32 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
Seungbeom Kim <musiphi  2008-07-08 05:28:04 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
Seungbeom Kim <musiphi  2008-07-08 05:28:05 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
"Daniel T." <  2008-07-08 20:27:18 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
Seungbeom Kim <musiphi  2008-07-09 03:28:15 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
Tony Delroy <tony_in_d  2008-07-09 03:28:07 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
"Daniel T." <  2008-07-09 13:27:44 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
Tony Delroy <tony_in_d  2008-07-10 03:16:05 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
Francis Glassborow <fr  2008-07-10 14:03:27 
Re: Changing coordinate systems in mid-development
Jonathan Thornburg <cl  2008-07-10 14:09:44 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
Tony Delroy <tony_in_d  2008-07-10 20:28:08 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
Tony Delroy <tony_in_d  2008-07-11 14:11:39 
Re: Public member variables acceptable?
"Daniel T." <  2008-08-09 23:47:55 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan12V112 Wed Aug 20 4:19:51 CDT 2008.